
Wrong drugs, misread scans led to more California disciplinary cases than fraud or DUIs, study finds
Key Takeaways
- Over half of disciplinary actions (52.3%) were categorized as medical knowledge deficits, while 43.7% involved non-knowledge issues such as DUI, fraud, or boundary violations.
- Disciplined physicians with knowledge deficits had lower first-attempt ABIM IM Certification pass rates (66.7% vs 78.0%), with a statistically significant difference (P = .048).
The board's own researchers found a gap in first-attempt exam pass rates between physicians disciplined for what they didn't know and those disciplined for other reasons.
Of 558 disciplinary actions taken against California physicians from 2011 to 2022, 52.3% were related to gaps in medical knowledge, according to a
The examples include prescribing an inappropriate drug, misreading an imaging study and ordering a high-risk procedure a patient didn't need.
The study was published online Oct. 27 in the Journal of Continuing Education in the Health Professions. It covered California physicians who hold an ABIM identification number. Another 43.7% of the actions had nothing to do with medical knowledge.
Those cases included DUI and fraud convictions and inappropriate relationships with patients. The remaining 3.9% couldn't be clearly classified.
Physicians disciplined for a knowledge gap were also less likely to have passed ABIM's Internal Medicine Certification Exam on their first attempt.
The researchers looked at 239 disciplined physicians who first took the exam between 1996 and 2022. Of those cited for a knowledge deficit, 66.7% had passed on the first try, compared with 78.0% of those disciplined for other reasons. The authors reported the difference as statistically significant (P = .048).
“When people hear that a doctor has faced disciplinary action, they may think of misconduct or unprofessional behavior; they may not think about gaps in what a doctor knows,” lead author Lauren M. Duhigg, M.P.H., a senior research associate at ABIM, said in a
How the cases were sorted
The researchers took every physician with an ABIM identification number who was disciplined in California between Jan. 1, 2011, and Dec. 31, 2022.
They pulled each physician's disciplinary records from the state medical board's website and used a systematic review process to decide whether each action involved a knowledge deficit. Medical board discipline can range from a public reprimand or probation to revocation of a license.
ABIM picked California because it has more active physicians than any other state and because its licensing board publishes detailed descriptions of each action.
The study is observational and covers only one state. The exam comparison covered fewer than half of the disciplined physicians.
According to the paper's conflict-of-interest statement, the authors are employed by the organizations they're affiliated with, and no grant or outside funding paid for the work. Co-author Furman S. McDonald, M.D., M.P.H., is ABIM's president and CEO.
A link ABIM has drawn before
The new paper builds on a
That group included physicians who never took the exam. Discipline rates fell as MOC exam scores rose. They didn't change based on how much continuing medical education (CME) a physician's state required for licensure.
McDonald led that study when he was an ABIM senior vice president. He
“Medicine changes continuously, and keeping pace with new evidence and standards of care is essential to patient safety,” said co-author Lorna Lynn, M.D., ABIM's senior vice president for health equity and medical assessment engagement. “Doctors can continue learning throughout their careers, and the association between exam performance and knowledge-related disciplinary actions points to the potential for assessment to identify and address gaps before they may place patients at risk.”
The recertification debate
Rheumatologist Mark Lopatin, M.D., retired from clinical practice in 2020 at age 63 rather than recertify with ABIM a third time. He described that decision to Rebekah Bernard, M.D., for a
“Patients put their trust in a physician's hands — their lives depend on us,” Lopatin said. “And to imply that physicians won't stay current without the American Board of Internal Medicine's enforcement is insulting.”
“They should be testing my due diligence by showing that I've followed through on my CME,” he said. “They can measure that and prove to the public that physicians are staying current.”
Neurologist Paul G. Mathew, M.D., also appeared on that episode. He joined the board of directors of the
“No physician practices without access to greater knowledge,” Mathew said. “If we have a question in clinic, we look at the medical literature to see what's up and coming.”
In October 2024, ABIM
“Physicians across all disciplines were clear that the two-year point requirement is confusing and did not provide added value,” McDonald said at the time. The requirement to earn 100 MOC points every five years stayed in place.
Related to this article









