
Retirement income for physicians: Why cash flow matters more than rate of return
Key Takeaways
- Sequence-of-returns risk becomes acute when retirees fund fixed withdrawals during downturns, potentially locking in losses and impairing long-term lifestyle sustainability.
- Reframing retirement planning around cash flow, not just total return, improves withdrawal discipline and can preserve principal through adverse market cycles.
Retired physicians who rely on monthly portfolio withdrawals risk selling low in a downturn. Here's how income investments such as preferred stocks, REITs and options-based ETFs can cover living costs and leave growth assets untouched.
Many investors follow the pattern of a hypothetical physician we’ll call Jason.
For most of Jason’s life, he has been a saver, someone accumulating retirement resources by investing.
As a successful physician, he earned a substantial income. Though his lifestyle has been commensurate with his earnings, he has still managed to accumulate significant wealth.
Since Jason retired, however, his investment accounts haven’t been growing as he originally expected because he has started to take
Worries begin
Recently, he has begun to worry about the prospect of market events that might irrevocably diminish his assets by forcing him to sell low to meet monthly cash needs.
Jason’s thinking: “If the market declines enough and I keep on taking monthly withdrawals, this will reduce my assets. Then, my retirement lifestyle might have to change. I wouldn’t be able to travel as much. Worse yet, I might have to give up my beach house.”
Jason is trying to adjust to his new status as a spender — someone living off their assets in retirement rather than a saver accumulating them while working.
Savers have it easy. When the market goes up, their assets grow. When it declines, they can buy additional shares at a discount. They don’t feel the pinch of lower stock values because they’re living off income, not account withdrawals.
Of course, the market downturns Jason has begun to fear are inevitable, given market history. The market has always gone through corrections and bear periods. And while it makes sense to be bullish over the long term, savers survive bear markets because of their cash flow and long time horizons.
Retirement flips this scenario. After retiring, investors are at the mercy of the market if they’re taking monthly withdrawals, as opposed to taking them strategically — when the market is up.
When people are still working and investing, many are inclined to overlook market risk because they’re not liquidating investments. They’re deriving the benefits of long-term growth without interruption from withdrawals because their incomes allow them to leave their investment accounts alone.
Cash flow is king
In retirement, Jason is ironically neglecting the very dynamic that enabled him to grow his wealth while working: cash flow, bringing in more money than he was spending.
Many investors attribute all the success of their portfolios to rate of return while underestimating the impact of regular contributions compounding over time.
Cash flow is what allows you to save and grow your wealth during your working years, and it’s what can give you peace of mind and stability in retirement.
One approach to supporting cash-flow needs is to rebalance a portfolio to include investments that tend to generate consistent income.
Holding
- Creating predictable monthly income, helping retirees enjoy a lifestyle closer to the one to which they became accustomed.
- Preventing investors from liquidating shares when the market is performing poorly. That keeps them invested through market cycles and can lead to higher returns in the long run.
- Relieving investors of anxiety over what the stock market is doing at any given moment. If the S&P 500 goes down 25% next year, it won’t impact their lifestyle.
Not bonds
When individual investors think about portfolio income, they tend to automatically think of bonds. But unbeknownst to many, there’s a class of non-bond investments structured expressly to provide income. These investments are usually traded as shares of equity, but they don’t behave like regular stocks.
By providing reliable dividends, income investments give investors cash that augments retirement income streams such as Social Security benefits. This enables retirees to leave their growth assets alone.
Income investments come in various forms. Examples include:
Preferred stocks . This is a sort of bond-stock hybrid that can pay substantial dividends, but with less volatility than common stocks. Rather than selecting individual preferred-share issues, a prohibitively heavy lift, individual investors should probably stick to funds with solid dividend histories. Ideally, investors would select preferred exchange-traded funds (ETFs) with the potential to recover from market declines and rebuild distributions (dividends) as conditions improve.Real estate investment trusts (REITs). These are landlord companies that own property and collect rents. As pass-through entities, REITs are required to pass along to investors at least 90% of their annual taxable income, resulting in substantial dividends.Options . Trading options is too complicated and too much work for the average individual investor, but various options strategies can be accessed through actively managed ETFs. Some ETFs use an options overlay alongside a market index, such as the S&P 500, with the goal of providing investors with income from option premiums.
Some investors overlook the need for investment income because they fear that holding too much cash or fixed-income investments will result in returns lower than those potentially available from stocks. This is a classic example of FOMO (fear of missing out).
Focusing on cash flow, rather than rate of return alone, can help retirees plan withdrawals in light of their income needs and portfolio resources. As cash flow helps maintain principal, making it more of a priority may enable some to retire earlier.
Not only can making cash flow the main focus ultimately get investors better results, but it can also help investors think about why money is important to them: to achieve life goals and bring peace of mind.
And after all, attaining the peace of mind that comes from financial security is the reason most people invest in the first place.
Too many forget that accumulating assets is a means to an end, not an end in itself.
Matthew Potter is an advisor in the Indianapolis office of Allworth Financial LP, a national investment advisory firm registered with the Securities and Exchange Commission.
Related to this article









