Medical Economics Expert Panel 12.2
News|Slideshows|November 19, 2026

Where one insurer dominates: 10 states with the least insurer competition

Fact checked by: Keith A. Reynolds
Listen
0:00 / 0:00

AMA data rank the states where insurer competition is weakest


For many physicians, there is only one commercial insurer in town that really matters at the negotiating table. In “Competition in health insurance: A comprehensive study of U.S. markets,” its 2026 report, the American Medical Association (AMA) found that 95% of metropolitan commercial markets were highly concentrated in 2025, and in nearly half, a single insurer held at least half the market. That imbalance can limit physicians’ leverage on payment and contract terms, especially in smaller independent practices. The AMA measured concentration with the Herfindahl-Hirschman Index (HHI), the same yardstick federal antitrust regulators use when they review mergers. The HHI adds up the squared market shares of every insurer in a market: A monopoly scores 10,000, and any market scoring above 1,800 is considered highly concentrated. This slideshow counts down the 10 states the AMA ranked as having the least competitive commercial health insurance markets, with the two largest insurers in each.

For more on the findings, read Medical Economics’ full report.


Related to this article

Qasim Faizan: ©WeBill Health
Starting Jan. 1, Medicare will pay 20% less for the lower-valued service when an office visit billed with modifier 25 falls on the same day as a zero-day global procedure. One claims report priced at local 2027 rates shows independent practices their exposure, and three documentation habits protect the visits that still qualify for full payment.
Vincent Cantone: ©WellSpan Health
With projected shortfalls of 86,000 to more than 187,000 physicians within a decade, burnout, an aging workforce and capped residency slots are squeezing supply. Here are the training, payment, prior authorization and workplace changes that could help close the gap.