Blog|Articles|November 19, 2026

Should your practice buy new, refurbished or leased medical equipment? How to compare total cost

Fact checked by: Todd Shryock
Listen
0:00 / 0:00

Key Takeaways

  • Total cost of ownership should incorporate acquisition/lease payments, installation/calibration, training, service, consumables, downtime opportunity cost, and resale or disposal to avoid misleading quote-based comparisons.
  • Manufacturer support duration for parts, service, and software security updates can be the dominant risk variable, particularly for networked devices vulnerable to legacy cybersecurity exposures.
SHOW MORE

The sticker price is rarely the biggest number in an equipment decision. A simple total-cost-of-ownership worksheet, a few pointed questions about support life and warranties, and a tax check with your accountant can help independent practices choose with confidence.

When a key piece of equipment reaches the end of its life, most practices compare sticker prices and move on. That’s understandable, but it can lead to the wrong choice. The price on the quote is often not the biggest number in the decision.

A better approach is to compare three paths side by side — new, refurbished and leased — over the full time the practice expects to use the equipment.

Start with total cost, not price

Total cost of ownership is a simple idea: add up everything the practice will spend on a device from the day it arrives to the day it leaves. For most clinical equipment, that includes:

  • Purchase price or lease payments
  • Delivery, installation and calibration
  • Staff training
  • Service contracts and repairs
  • Consumables and accessories
  • Downtime, including lost appointments when the device is out of service
  • Resale, trade-in or disposal at the end

Two quotes that look far apart can end up close once service and downtime are counted. Two that look close can end up far apart.

Ask about support life

The most overlooked number in an equipment decision is how long the manufacturer will keep supporting the model. Once parts or service stop, even a well-built device can become hard to keep running.

This matters for all three options. A new model may be supported for years. A refurbished unit of an older model may be close to its end of support. A lease may shift that risk to the lessor, depending on the contract.

Software adds another layer. ECRI, the independent patient safety organization, named “cybersecurity risks from legacy medical devices” one of its Top 10 Health Technology Hazards for 2026. For connected devices, practices should ask how long security updates will continue.

The case for each option

New equipment usually comes with the longest manufacturer support, the most complete warranty and the latest features. It also costs the most up front.

Refurbished equipment can cost less, but the quality depends on who did the work and how. The FDA’s 2024 guidance on remanufacturing of medical devices draws a regulatory line between servicing and remanufacturing, which is a good reason to ask sellers for a written description of the work done, the parts replaced and the testing performed. Warranty terms on refurbished equipment vary widely, so they deserve a close read.

Leasing spreads cost over time and may include service or upgrade options. The trade-off is that the practice may pay more over the full term and, depending on how the lease is structured, may not own the equipment at the end.

Don’t forget taxes

Tax treatment can tip the balance. The IRS’s Publication 946 explains how businesses can recover equipment costs through depreciation or the Section 179 deduction. For tax years beginning in 2026, the publication lists the maximum Section 179 deduction at $2.56 million, reduced dollar for dollar once qualifying property placed in service exceeds $4.09 million.

Few practices will come near those limits. What matters more is how the practice’s taxable income, the timing of the purchase and the choice between buying and leasing interact. That’s a question for the practice’s accountant before the contract is signed, not after.

A simple worksheet

To compare options fairly, a practice can build a one-page sheet with a column for each path and rows for:

  • Upfront cost
  • Installation and training
  • Expected annual service and repair cost
  • Consumables per year
  • Expected years of use
  • Estimated downtime per year and its cost
  • End-of-life value or disposal cost
  • Tax effect, from the accountant

Multiply the annual rows by the years of use, add the one-time rows and compare totals. The math doesn’t need to be precise. It needs to be consistent across options.

Questions to ask every seller

Whatever direction a practice leans, the same questions help:

  • How long will the manufacturer support this model, including software?
  • What does the warranty cover, who performs repairs and how fast?
  • What’s included in the price, and what’s extra?
  • For refurbished units: What was done, by whom and to whose specifications?
  • Can you share the serial number before purchase?

Sellers who answer clearly and in writing make comparison easy. Sellers who don’t are telling the practice something too.

The takeaway

Equipment decisions often get made under pressure, when something has already broken. Practices that keep a simple total-cost worksheet and a list of standard questions can move fast without guessing. The cheapest quote and the cheapest choice aren’t always the same thing.

Michael Mauritson is sales manager at Phase Medical Partners, which sells new and refurbished medical equipment. That gives him a commercial interest in how practices buy equipment. This article doesn’t endorse any vendor or product. He can be reached at phasemedicalpartners.com.


Related to this article