- Revenue Cycle Management
- COVID-19
- Reimbursement
- Diabetes Awareness Month
- Risk Management
- Patient Retention
- Staffing
- Medical Economics® 100th Anniversary
- Coding and documentation
- Business of Endocrinology
- Telehealth
- Physicians Financial News
- Cybersecurity
- Cardiovascular Clinical Consult
- Locum Tenens, brought to you by LocumLife®
- Weight Management
- Business of Women's Health
- Practice Efficiency
- Finance and Wealth
- EHRs
- Remote Patient Monitoring
- Sponsored Webinars
- Medical Technology
- Billing and collections
- Acute Pain Management
- Exclusive Content
- Value-based Care
- Business of Pediatrics
- Concierge Medicine 2.0 by Castle Connolly Private Health Partners
- Practice Growth
- Concierge Medicine
- Business of Cardiology
- Implementing the Topcon Ocular Telehealth Platform
- Malpractice
- Influenza
- Sexual Health
- Chronic Conditions
- Technology
- Legal and Policy
- Money
- Opinion
- Vaccines
- Practice Management
- Patient Relations
- Careers
Changes in medical licensing exam create new problems
At-risk students and diversity both suffer from changing the first part of the exam to pass/fail
The United States Medical Licensing Examination three-step test was recently changed so that step 1 is pass/fail instead of assigning a score to students. Prior to the change, the higher the score, the more likely the student would match into their desired residency program and specialty. The score provided residency directors a way to assess student applications in an equal manner.
Changes in USMLE create new problems: ©Arrowsmith2 - stock.adobe.com
In January 2022, step 1 of the exam was changed to pass/fail largely to reduce the stress and anxiety prevalent among medical school students and improve their overall mental health. Step 2 still awards a three-digit score.
TrueLearn surveyed 250 medical educators to see what effect the change to pass/fail was having and if it had unintended consequences.
Less than half (41%) of survey respondents indicated that while students will be less stressed and have better quality of life, 58% believe students will spend less time preparing for step 1, and 31% said students will be at-risk for underperforming on step 2.
Diversity also is seen to have taken a big hit thanks to the change to pass/fail. The survey revealed that 40% believe students – especially less privileged ones – will have a tougher time matching to their top choices for residency. The challenge for residency directors is that without a score, they tend to rely on the prestige of the school attended because they have little else to go on. Students from less prestigious schools therefore will have a more difficult time.
The top three challenges indicated by the survey were identifying at-risk students (39%), ensuring students retain basic science and preclinical content to ensure optimal step 2 performance (38%), and measuring board exam readiness and performance within the curriculum (36%). Only 26% said they had the data necessary to identify at-risk students.
The biggest change at medical schools is 31% said they have communicated to students that the difficulty of the test has not changed, just the grading method.
Read the full report here.
