Jeffrey Pearson, DO

Editor's Note: We asked our editorial board members to share their opinions of the Supreme Court ruling on the Affordable Care Act. Here's what Jeffrey Pearson, DO, said.

What my patients and I really need from the U.S. government is not the mishmosh more commonly referred to as the Affordable Care Act (ACA). From my readings (not of the ACA text itself, because I doubt that few, if any, have actually waded through the entire actual 4.5-MB PDF file or the 2,409 printed pages into which this translates), the only thing the act has going for my patients is its title and intentions. Bear in mind that I am not partisan to any particular political party. All I know is what my staff and I must deal with on a daily and ongoing basis.

To find the problem with the status quo, I quote Deep Throat of Watergate fame: “Follow the money.” The way that things currently work is that both patients and providers are at the mercy of the insurance companies. They control the entire game from start to finish. They select who is a good risk for them to insure, what to charge them for coverage, what to cover and what to exclude, and what to pay providers.  Their sole fiscal responsibilities are to their shareholders; hence, it’s best to take in lots of money and not pay it out. Simple economics, and it works well enough for most commodities, i.e. any marketable item produced to satisfy wants or needs.

However, I submit that the health and wellbeing of humans is too important and far-reaching, impacting societies as a whole and hence should not be treated as a commodity.

Obtaining insurance is a notoriously difficult process fraught with frustration.  Any process that encourages honest people to be somewhat less than honest during the application process or with their physicians has something wrong with it. How many of us have received requests from patients, sometimes begging us, not to enter certain subjects into their medical records for fear of losing or paying more for their insurance?

Looking on the provider side, it doesn’t matter what a physician might want to charge (presumably taking our legitimate costs into concern); unless we have created a concierge practice, many of us are at the mercy of those who set our fees and can do little about it. For example, in San Diego where I practice, our fees have been based on rural rates ever since I moved here, despite the fact that our overhead costs clearly deserve an urban classification. These lower reimbursement rates across the board have made it difficult for solo practitioners such as me to be able to afford bringing on additional physicians, for example.

We have the federal government to thank for this incorrect classification, and they’ve known about this for as long as I can remember, yet it has not been fixed in the 20 plus years that I’ve practiced in the county. That being said, if it is designed properly, I am entirely behind a national government-sponsored single-payer health care system, as this would greatly simplify the lives of both my patients and my staff.

Here’s a dream: Imagine patients of all socioeconomic groups walking into a hospital or physician’s office and simply showing their national identification card and receiving appropriate care. No haggling whatsoever. Staffs wouldn’t have to waste valuable minutes with each and every patient on a daily basis verifying their plans, eligibility, and co-pay amounts. No arguing over what’s covered and what’s not. There would be many very happy offices. (And the money saved by eliminating this bureaucratic hell could be used to reimburse all physicians fairly for their skills and for what they do. We physicians should not be divided over reimbursement issues, e.g., primary care versus specialty rates. The problem lies with the insurance system, not with us. We should work together to develop a single system that is fair for all.)

I worked as a volunteer camp physician in Canada 2 years ago and had to take a teenager to the emergency department of a local hospital for suspected appendicitis. A national medical card was flashed and the kid was in. Sure, some will argue that you’d have harder access to some technologies such as computed tomography and magnetic resonance imaging, but that’s Canada. In my neck of the woods, there are so many of these machines that the radiology groups market directly to the general public, offering highly discounted screening studies for preventive health.

The ACA touts that all Americans would have access to healthcare by requiring individuals to purchase their own insurance. Great. Make the insurance companies richer and even more powerful.  Per a recent 

 article, a single taxpayer, currently uninsured, making $70,000 a year, would have the option of purchasing private insurance for >$4,000 year or pay a penalty of somewhere around $620. When money is tight, as it certainly is in today’s economy, I think that it’s a safe bet that this taxpayer will remain uninsured, and this will definitely not improve the state of healthcare in our country.

Government is designed to serve the people and do “the right thing” even when it’s not the most popular. Look back at integration in the school systems as an example. I attribute the government’s historical inability to create a simplified, single-payer system to the influence of the powerful insurance lobby. However, it’s about time that our elected officials step up and do the right thing for their constituents. The obscene amount of money that is currently being skimmed by the insurance and pharmaceutical vultures would be freed up and could be used to support such a system.

There are many who believe that healthcare is not an innate human right. In fact, they’re right. We are, after all, simply animals inhabiting this planet just like any other. Creatures who encounter difficulties must find ways to cope or perish. This happens all of the time, and the result is evolution, i.e., survival of the fittest.

As humans, we consider ourselves above all other life forms on this satellite hurtling through space. Our higher cognitive functions are associated with a greater capacity for caring, with many of us constantly struggling to make this world a better place to live. Healthcare might not be a human right, but fixing our broken system is the right thing, the humane thing, to do for our fellow man.

Waltman: I am a ‘Medicare for all’ advocate

Wax: Decision is dark chapter in American history

Articles

Medical Economics editorial board member Jeffrey K. Pearson, DO, shares his opinion about the Supreme Court's Affordable Care Act ruling.

Pearson: Healthcare reform is the right thing to do

Some people, however, forget that many of us went into this profession for reasons other than money, such as helping people in need, that is, the so-called "psychic reward." And, heaven knows, for many of us primary care docs, the psychic reward has been a significant part of the equation because for years payments/reimbursements have not been where they should be. 

Helping others makes us feel good. It's a great stress reducer, and it's the right thing to do as well. 

Attending patient funerals is another opportunity to show how much we cared for our patients. We can provide family support, if needed, and the looks of gratitude on the faces of the family members tell me that I'm doing the right thing by being there.  

On a happier note, I perform magic for my patients on a daily basis. A magician member of the Academy of Magical Arts, I often use comedy magic to make doctor visits less stressful. Last year, I saw a delightful 78-year-old woman for the first time. After addressing her concerns, I asked her if she'd like to see some magic and performed a card trick. She said, "I've always loved magic. In fact, I used to work for a magician." "Which one?" I asked. "Harry Blackstone Sr.," she replied. "I was the girl he cut in half on stage for three years!" Thinking fast, I performed another trick that involved her participation. Now, I can proudly claim that I shared assistants with the great Harry Blackstone Sr.! 

Finally, one other fun thing that I've done on a day off is to invite some seniors for lunch at the restaurant of their choice. In a society that tends to discard things that get old, too often the elderly - and the valuable sacrifices and contributions that they've made - are ignored. I've heard some wonderful stories during these lunches, including from one woman who served as a missionary in Africa! 

To recall an important lesson I learned in college: "Those who forget the past are doomed to repeat it." Our senior patients harbor a vast wealth of information and experience. Tap into them and you'll find yourself with some extremely rewarding experiences for which there is no ICD code. 

Jeffrey K. Pearson, DO, is a family physician in San Marcos, California. Send your feedback to 

Some people forget that many of us went into this profession for reasons other than money, such as helping people in need, that is, the so-called 'psychic reward.'

Viewpoint: On pursuing a career to help people in need

A few weeks ago, one of my patients offered me a coupon for our local office supply store. "Doc," he said, "you're going to need this come January."

He mentioned a story he had heard on the news about how doctors would no longer be able to receive free pens from drug companies. What a stupid idea, I thought. Who cares about free pens? Then I recalled my experience at the Pri-Med West conference a few years back. 

In many ways, it was like any physician conference. It was barely past Easter, and the exhibition hall in Anaheim, California, rippled with the excitement of another scavenger hunt-only these weren't kiddies seeking brightly colored eggs. They were primary care physicians of all shapes, colors, and sizes scampering about like hamsters in a maze, scooping up every freebie in sight and hurriedly stuffing them into their large drug-name-embossed tote bags. Walk out with the heaviest bag, and you're our winner for the day.

There are two categories of scavenger-hunt participant at any conference: physicians and their spouses. They are divided into two-person teams easily distinguishable by the color of their oversized drug-company bags-the first acquisition for any serious conference scavenger. Anything not nailed down is fair game. At one point, I observed a woman making off with a stapler.

Techniques vary. Perhaps the boldest of them is what pharmaceutical reps call "the swoop." The physician suddenly appears from out of nowhere and quickly sweeps all of the display items (pens, treats, notepads, stickers) into his bag. And then, in a flash, he is gone without a trace, presumably back home to restock his penless office.

(And those pens go fast. I watched reps place boxes of them on a table, and as soon as they turned away, one doc took an entire box! One can only imagine what goes through the minds of airport security screeners as they scrutinize the oddball contents of these freebie bags.)

More artful are the magician wannabes, those who employ their skills of misdirection and sleight of hand in the hope of netting perhaps two additional writing utensils. They strike up a conversation with the booth rep, then in a moment of inattention, shoot their hands across the table, grasping whatever handouts they can hold and sticking them into the waiting bag before the rep returns. One particularly enterprising physician deposited an entire bowl of mints into her bag, after first scanning the room to ensure that no one was watching.

Observers of this phenomenon know that nothing reveals the seamy underbelly of medicine like an exhibit booth that's run out of freebies. Tempers flare, indignation soars, and retribution awaits at the adjacent table that still has a few refrigerator magnets left.

Which brings us to one small point of note: Exhibition reps do not have special powers. When an item runs out, there is nothing they can do to create more. Not even your yelling and screaming can alter this fact. I know; I have seen it firsthand.

Of course, not all that I've taken from my conference experiences has left me so discouraged. For one thing, I did come away with some really cool pens. And I hear they'll have to last me for a while.

Jeffrey K. Pearson, DO, practices family and sports medicine in San Marcos, California. Send your feedback to 

Nothing reveals the seamy underbelly of medicine like an exhibit booth that's run out of freebies.

Author | Jeffrey Pearson, DO

Articles

Pearson: Healthcare reform is the right thing to do

Viewpoint: On pursuing a career to help people in need

Viewpoint: Who cares about free pens?