Save blame for later, it’s time to work together to solve the opioid crisis

June 27, 2016
Rashmee Patil, MD
Rashmee Patil, MD

The patient encounters may vary, but the public health issue remains the same: We have an opioid crisis in America and the numbers prove it.

Every day I entered her hospital room it felt as though I was entering her actual bedroom. Any empty space I could see was covered with personal memorabilia: cards from friends and loved ones, flowers, schoolbooks and packs of her favorite candy livened an otherwise dull and unwelcoming hospital room. She had made this space her home and I didn't blame her. After a diagnosis of endocarditis that had affected one of her major heart valves, she was going to receive six weeks of antibiotics through a peripherally inserted central catheter, and she would spend those six weeks in this exact room.

Every few days I would check in, making sure she wasn't having any fevers and that the site of the catheter was clean. Beginning my exam, I would auscultate her chest to listen for irregular heart sounds. Going through the same routine each time, she had come to anticipate my next move. "I never thought I would be in this position," she told me one day. I loosened my stethoscope from my ears instead of beginning my exam.  

 

Further reading: What should physiciand do about the opioid crisis?

 

She told me she was 22 when it started. She began drinking more heavily on weekends with friends to relieve some of the stress she was feeling in her job as a teacher. Then one weekend, one of those friends asked her if she wanted to try a line of cocaine, and she did. Surprised and euphoric from the high, she quickly dabbled in other substances and eventually advanced to intravenous drugs.

After several weeks, she found herself injecting heroin every other day, except this time it was not just on weekends when she was drunk. She was shooting up in her office between teaching classes during the day and in her bedroom when her parents were outside watching the nightly news. Each attempt to satisfy her need for a high grew more risky. She was taking trips to surrounding cities where she had heard heroin was cheaper but not telling anyone where she was. She admitted she was ashamed, but felt she couldn't stop. 

 

Even more opioid coverage: Physicians don't want hands tied by opioid reform

 

I listened as she talked, partly empathizing but not fully understanding how a seemingly well-educated and highly-functioning young person with a meaningful job and a supportive family could so quickly take a turn toward a much darker path. She explained to me that because heroin was so accessible, she easily began to seek it out through different buyers on her own, despite being a novice. Her own hunger for the drug scared her.

I thought to myself that maybe her diagnosis was the jolt she needed. Instead of falling deeper into the abyss of addiction, she was now sitting in a hospital bed, in a controlled setting, and forced to deal with her mental demons every day for the next six weeks. Of course, her story was one of many I had heard since starting to work at this rural community hospital, and with each patient encounter I was becoming less and less surprised by the details.

Next: The public health issue remains the same

 

Over the past several months, I have divided my time as a hospitalist between a major metropolitan city and a small, rural town in New York State. In the hospital where I work there is an addiction unit, and I am often called for medical consultations for patients withdrawing from their substance of choice. The substances vary, but almost every patient has had an experience with opioids in one form or another. In fact, I have seen more overdoses from opioids in this small community over the past several months than I have in the five years I trained and worked in medicine in New York City. I have seen a 56-year-old woman with chronic back pain who overdosed on oxycodone, found unconscious on the kitchen floor by her husband. I have seen a 21-year-old man come in with respiratory failure after shooting up “just one more bag” of heroin. And more recently, I have seen tragic, accidental deaths from fentanyl, a drug that is showing up on the street in counterfeit pills being passed off as oxycodone or Xanax.

The patient encounters may vary, but the public health issue remains the same: We have an opioid crisis in America and the numbers, like my experience in this rural town, prove it.

 

Related: There is still time for Congress to take healthcare action

 

According to the most recent data from the New York State Department of Health, opioid related deaths in central New York have increased by 2,900% since 2004. Similarly, the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) reports that an estimated 51 people die each day in the U.S. from overdoses related to prescription opioids. This number has risen five-fold since 1999.

Between 1999 and 2010, there was a 400% increase in sales of prescription opioid pain relievers in this country. Interestingly, however, there was no increase in the amount of pain Americans reported in that same period. As the White House, the CDC and other federal and state agencies scramble to find solutions to the current opioid problem, the role that doctors play is coming back to center stage. 

In March, the CDC released new guidelines for physicians prescribing opioids, recommending that doctors try less-addictive drugs, such as ibuprofen, before prescribing highly addictive pills and that they only give a few days' supply in most cases. The recommendations are meant for primary care doctors and do not apply to prescriptions for patients receiving cancer or end-of-life treatment, or to patients who have had surgery. These guidelines come after a growing backlash from some physician groups and organizations who have opposed the practice of opioid prescriptions for routine pain.

 

More healthcare news: As insurers leave Obamacare exchanges, doctors pay the price

 

Many physicians have prescribed opioids to patients for conditions such as back pain and arthritic pain over the past two decades. This came as a result of pharmaceutical companies and some medical experts attesting that opioids could be used to treat common conditions without the fear of addiction. Later those claims would be found to be false even though drug companies have profited from a $2 billion industry of popularly marketed and sold drugs such as Oxycontin, Percocet and Vicodin. Though some physicians and agencies do not support the guidelines, the soaring death toll and data supporting the opioid crisis have brought together many doctors and regulators who were previously on opposite sides of the debate. 

Next:  The imminent threat must be addressed now

 

Though the CDC guidelines and other new measures from government regulators such as the Food and Drug Administration (FDA) are targeting physicians, the crisis we are facing has not occurred just as a result of physicians overprescribing. Equally complicit in the crisis have been pharmaceutical companies advertising opioids as safe and not addictive, as well as governmental agencies such as the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS) deciding that a patient’s satisfaction score during a hospitalization is as important in reimbursement as the patient’s survival and whether they obtained a hospital-acquired infection.

 

Further reading: GOP Doctors Caucus looking at abitious 2016

 

When part of the patient satisfaction score is linked directly to the management of pain during their hospital stay, there is undeniably a pressure for physicians to provide opioids to patients even if they feel they may not necessarily need them. Arguably these measures were initiated in legislature years after the culture of treating pain changed in the U.S. medical community as a result of a campaign by the American Pain Society (APS) to treat pain as the “fifth vital sign.” Once this new perception of treating pain as a vital sign caught on, organizations such as the Veterans Health Administration and the Joint Commission on Accreditation of Healthcare Organizations began to adopt the slogan and called on physicians to manage patients’ pain.

But just as any slogan or plan, there must be regulations in place after implementation. Many physicians took “manage pain” to mean “prescribe opioids” and this led to a now billion-dollar industry. Ultimately, the blame can be placed on many, but the imminent threat to public health that the opioid crisis promises must be addressed now by cooperation between physicians, legislators, pharmaceutical companies and the regulatory boards who oversee them.

Fortunately, my patient finished her six-week course of antibiotics and was discharged home. She enrolled in outpatient rehabilitation and, with the help of family and friends, regained her self-determination to live a clean and sober life. Though her outer appearance did not explain the turmoil that addiction had inflicted on her life when I first met her, hearing her story opened my eyes, yet again, to the vastness of this epidemic’s reach.

The morning after she was discharged, I came to the hospital, printed my daily census, and looked for any new patients. There was a new patient admitted overnight who had filled the room adjacent to hers. Admitting diagnosis: opioid overdose.

 

Rashmee Patil is a board-certified internal medicine physician practicing in New York State.