Medical Economics Logo
  • Physicians Money Digest

  • Physicians Financial News

  • Physicians Practice

  • Chief Healthcare Executive

  • Patient Care Online

All NewsCareersLegalMoneyOpinionPhysicians Financial NewsPractice ManagementTechnology
Around the PracticeBetween The LinesClinical ConsultExpert InterviewsMedical Economics PulseMedical World NewsOff The Charts PodcastsPhysician ReportPrimaryViewSlideshows
Academy
Conference CoverageConference Listing
Medical EconomicsPatient Care SupplementSponsored ContentSponsored ResourcesSupplements And Featured Publications
CME/CEJob BoardSubscribe
Financial Advisor Guide
CareersCareersCareersCareersCareersCareersCareersCareersCareers
LegalLegalLegalLegalLegal
Medical Device & TechnologyMedical Device & TechnologyMedical Device & TechnologyMedical Device & TechnologyMedical Device & TechnologyMedical Device & TechnologyMedical Device & TechnologyMedical Device & TechnologyMedical Device & TechnologyMedical Device & TechnologyMedical Device & Technology
Opinion
Physician's Money DigestPhysician's Money DigestPhysician's Money DigestPhysician's Money Digest
PolicyPolicyPolicyPolicyPolicyPolicy
Practice FinancePractice FinancePractice FinancePractice FinancePractice FinancePractice FinancePractice Finance
Practice ManagementPractice ManagementPractice ManagementPractice ManagementPractice ManagementPractice ManagementPractice ManagementPractice Management
Practice TechnologyPractice TechnologyPractice TechnologyPractice TechnologyPractice TechnologyPractice TechnologyPractice Technology
Screening
Special ReportsSpecial ReportsSpecial Reports
Spotlight -
  • The benefits of a physician MBA program
  • Concierge Medicine 2.0 by Castle Connolly Private Health Partners
  • Physician Bootcamp
  • Physician Report
CareersCareersCareersCareersCareersCareersCareersCareersCareers
LegalLegalLegalLegalLegal
Medical Device & TechnologyMedical Device & TechnologyMedical Device & TechnologyMedical Device & TechnologyMedical Device & TechnologyMedical Device & TechnologyMedical Device & TechnologyMedical Device & TechnologyMedical Device & TechnologyMedical Device & TechnologyMedical Device & Technology
Opinion
Physician's Money DigestPhysician's Money DigestPhysician's Money DigestPhysician's Money Digest
PolicyPolicyPolicyPolicyPolicyPolicy
Practice FinancePractice FinancePractice FinancePractice FinancePractice FinancePractice FinancePractice Finance
Practice ManagementPractice ManagementPractice ManagementPractice ManagementPractice ManagementPractice ManagementPractice ManagementPractice Management
Practice TechnologyPractice TechnologyPractice TechnologyPractice TechnologyPractice TechnologyPractice TechnologyPractice Technology
Screening
Special ReportsSpecial ReportsSpecial Reports
    • Academy
    • CME/CE
    • Job Board
    • Subscribe
Advertisement

Article

April 23, 2010

Protect yourself from diagnosis-related lawsuits

In diagnosis cases, you don't have to be right, but you do have to be reasonable.

Key Points

Here is an actual malpractice case in which the claim was failure to diagnose: Mrs. A, an 82-year-old female, saw Dr. B, her primary care physician, on day 1 complaining of abdominal pain. The physical exam was unrevealing; vital signs were stable, and the complete blood count test results were normal. No definitive diagnosis was made. The patient was instructed to return if the pain got worse or if other symptoms developed.

On day 11, Mrs. A returned with more complaints of abdominal pain. An exam revealed the patient in no apparent distress. She had a soft abdomen, normal peristalsis, and no rebound. Her vital signs were normal, and a complete exam with a battery of tests was unremarkable.

the abdomen. She had a sudden, severe bout of abdominal pain and was taken to the operating room with a diagnosis of a leaking aortic aneurysm. Mrs. A died during surgery.

Mrs. A's daughter sued Dr. B, the surgeon, and the hospital for malpractice and wrongful death. The jury returned a defense verdict. (The cost of litigation was around $50,000.)

Why did the jury find for the defense? Mainly because the jury believed that Dr. B had been reasonable in his diagnosis. It also was helpful that damages were small because Mrs. A was 82 years old, not working, and living with her daughter. Also, proximate cause was weak because experts testified that the result probably would have been the same even if the aortic aneurysm had been diagnosed 11 days earlier.

Other important components of a malpractice decision:

The author is a health law attorney in Mt. Kisco, New York, and a Medical Economics consultant. She may be reached at [email protected]. Malpractice Consult deals with questions on common professional liability issues. Unfortunately, we cannot offer specific legal advice. If you have a general question or a topic you would like to see covered here, please send it to [email protected]
.

Newsletter

Stay informed and empowered with Medical Economics enewsletter, delivering expert insights, financial strategies, practice management tips and technology trends — tailored for today’s physicians.

Subscribe Now!
Related Videos
The new standard for medical malpractice: A conversation with Daniel G. Aaron, M.D., J.D.
The new standard for medical malpractice: What to watch for
The new standard for medical malpractice: A step toward ending defensive medicine?
The new standard for medical malpractice: Can doctors be liable for doing what everyone else does?
The new standard for medical malpractice: What makes a clinical guideline legally defensible?
The new standard for medical malpractice: What it means for day-to-day practice
The new standard for medical malpractice: What changed?
The new standard for medical malpractice: Why the law just changed
ACP policy update 2025: A conversation with Brian E. Outland, PhD
ACP policy update 2025 interview
Related Content
Advertisement
Matt Coursen: ©JLL
July 9th 2025

Does your real estate support the growth plans of your private practice?

Off the Chart: A Business of Medicine Podcast - Ep. 68: Hidden risks of prescribing GLP-1 drugs with Ericka L. Adler, J.D., of Roetzel & Andress
June 9th 2025

Ep. 68: Hidden risks of prescribing GLP-1 drugs with Ericka L. Adler, J.D., of Roetzel & Andress

Andrea Greco, SVP of healthcare safety at CENTEGIX
June 26th 2025

Safety starts with trust: Reassessing real-time location systems in health care

Off the Chart: A Business of Medicine Podcast - Ep. 64: The new standard for medical malpractice with Daniel G. Aaron, MD, JD
May 12th 2025

Ep. 64: The new standard for medical malpractice with Daniel G. Aaron, MD, JD

Before joining a physician group, make sure you understand the agreement: ©Syahrir - stock.adobe.com
June 20th 2025

Key considerations for physicians joining or forming a group practice

Jared Kaplan: ©Indigo
June 2nd 2025

Redefining medical malpractice insurance to help physicians thrive

Related Content
Advertisement
Matt Coursen: ©JLL
July 9th 2025

Does your real estate support the growth plans of your private practice?

Off the Chart: A Business of Medicine Podcast - Ep. 68: Hidden risks of prescribing GLP-1 drugs with Ericka L. Adler, J.D., of Roetzel & Andress
June 9th 2025

Ep. 68: Hidden risks of prescribing GLP-1 drugs with Ericka L. Adler, J.D., of Roetzel & Andress

Andrea Greco, SVP of healthcare safety at CENTEGIX
June 26th 2025

Safety starts with trust: Reassessing real-time location systems in health care

Off the Chart: A Business of Medicine Podcast - Ep. 64: The new standard for medical malpractice with Daniel G. Aaron, MD, JD
May 12th 2025

Ep. 64: The new standard for medical malpractice with Daniel G. Aaron, MD, JD

Before joining a physician group, make sure you understand the agreement: ©Syahrir - stock.adobe.com
June 20th 2025

Key considerations for physicians joining or forming a group practice

Jared Kaplan: ©Indigo
June 2nd 2025

Redefining medical malpractice insurance to help physicians thrive

About
Advertise
Contact Us
Editorial Staff
Job Board
Terms and Conditions
Contributor Guidelines
Privacy Policy
Do Not Sell My Personal Information
Contact Info

2 Commerce Drive
Cranbury, NJ 08512

609-716-7777

© 2025 MJH Life Sciences

All rights reserved.