Medical Economics Expert Panel 12.2
|Articles|March 24, 2015

Cardiologists need to engage in tort reform

Medical liability concerns still rate high on the list of concerns by cardiologists, despite State tort reforms in the past decade that have resulted in fewer claims made against physicians and subsequent decreased malpractice insurance pricing.

Medical liability concerns still rate high on the list of concerns by cardiologists, despite State tort reforms in the past decade that have resulted in fewer claims made against physicians and subsequent decreased malpractice insurance pricing.

However, the pendulum could swing back to State tort reforms that are more lawyer friendly and could result in more numerous and higher jury awards coupled with an increase in the cost of malpractice insurance pricing.

“Liability concerns are still number 3 on a list of 10 or 12 issues that cardiologists worry about the most, right behind compensation and general healthcare delivery issues,” said Joseph S. Wilson, MD, CEO  and Chairman of MagMutual Insurance Group of Atlanta, GA. , who spoke on the shifts in State tort reform that swing from favoring the interests of physicians and those of lawyers during his presentation at the ACC meeting, entitled “State Tort Reforms: Implications for Cardiologists and Cardiac Surgeons.”

Given the cycles of medical liability issues, it is important that physicians get involved at the state level to help maintain the gains made over the past decade that have shifted toward more physician-friendly tort reforms.

Dr. Wilson cited legislation passed in Texas in 2003 that, among other reforms, capped the amount of non-economic damages at $250,000. Since this reform was enacted, the insurance market in Texas has stabilized, he said, with a significant decrease in malpractice pricing and a growth in the number of physicians practicing.

“This is a time for tort activity at the state level,” Wilson emphasized. “Each time we address tort reform, we’ve become complacent and we’ve allowed that pendulum to swing back toward liabilities issues that negatively impact physicians and patients.”

As such, Wilson encourages cardiologists to get involved, such as in their local ACC chapters, and to not only think about liability but act on it.

“We need to look at change that benefits the provider, the doctors, the cardiologists, and the patients,” he emphasized, adding that cardiologists need to take advantage of the current opportunity to guard against the pendulum swinging back toward a more lawyer-friendly focus as it has in the past 3 cycles. “This gives us the opportunity at the state level to try to get innovative and creative.”


Related to this article

Vincent Cantone: ©WellSpan Health
With projected shortfalls of 86,000 to more than 187,000 physicians within a decade, burnout, an aging workforce and capped residency slots are squeezing supply. Here are the training, payment, prior authorization and workplace changes that could help close the gap.
Qasim Faizan: ©WeBill Health
Starting Jan. 1, Medicare will pay 20% less for the lower-valued service when an office visit billed with modifier 25 falls on the same day as a zero-day global procedure. One claims report priced at local 2027 rates shows independent practices their exposure, and three documentation habits protect the visits that still qualify for full payment.