UPDATE: Focus on Practice

September 3, 2004

Malpractice caps; drug reimportation

Jump to:Choose article section...Study: Maybe flat caps aren't the way to go Missionary work from your easy chair Canada moves against doctors who enable reimportation Buy a medical device and get liability coverage too Our Web Poll

Study: Maybe flat caps aren't the way to go

Federal and state lawmakers are increasingly looking at caps on damages as a solution to the growing malpractice crisis. Now two studies of California jury verdicts that were subjected to the state's $250,000 cap on noneconomic damages give them more to think about.

Researchers at both Harvard's School of Public Health and the RAND Institute for Civil Justice found that the reduction in total award was greatest for plaintiffs whose quality of life was most severely diminished. For example, according to the Harvard study, the reductions imposed on jury awards for a grave injury were seven times larger than those for a minor injury, with the largest proportional reductions centered on pain and disfigurement. In addition, RAND researchers suggest that because the California law combines award caps and a sliding scale for attorneys' fees, the difference between the defendants' savings and the reduction in plaintiffs' net recoveries may result more from reduced attorneys fees than from the cap on damages.

ErrorInjuryEconomic damagesNoneconomic damages prior to capTotal award after cap was imposed% reduction in award
Perforation of duodenum during sphincterotomySevere pain, weight loss scarring, multiple reconstructive surgeries$11,000$4.7 million$261,00094%
Failure to inform of non- surgical options; substandard surgery to repair injury to sphincter; failure to manage post-operative complicationsAnal incontinence106,0001.9 million356,00081
Failure to diagnose fracture in diabetic patient; failure to order X-raysLoss of majority of heel, scarring, disfigurement37,0001.4 million287,00080
Misdiagnosis of fibrocystic condition as cancerousUnnecessary mastectomy, multiple reconstructive surgeries78,0001.5 million328,00078

Missionary work from your easy chair

WorldFriendshipPlace, a new Internet-based medical charity, is looking for US doctors willing to lend their expertise to colleagues in underdeveloped nations. Requests for help usually come from practitioners who lack the level of expertise required to treat a specific condition or are working under adverse conditions. Through live and taped online communication, WFP volunteers provide the necessary medical training, technology, and case management.

To learn more about the program, go to www.worldfriendshipplace.org.

Canada moves against doctors who enable reimportation

While the tug of war over reimporting prescription drugs goes on between states and the FDA, Canada has begun sanctioning physicians who countersign US prescriptions without seeing the patient. Medical authorities found a general practitioner in British Columbia guilty of unprofessional conduct and failure to meet the standard of care for his role in enabling US residents to obtain Canadian drugs. In addition to receiving a reprimand, the doctor was fined $25,000 by The College of Physicians & Surgeons of British Columbia.

For practical advice on this subject, see "When patients want to buy meds online," in this issue.

Buy a medical device and get liability coverage too

In a first-of-its-kind program, a Canadian manufacturer of aesthetic medical devices for cosmetic procedures is offering any US physician who buys its products affordable malpractice coverage as well. Through Hub International, an insurance brokerage firm, Toronto-based Syneron says it enables physicians to buy flexible, comprehensive coverage for themselves and their staffs at a lower premium than they could obtain on their own.

Our Web Poll

 

Joan Rose. UPDATE: Focus on Practice. Medical Economics Sep. 3, 2004;81:6.